I did the reviews of the Clinique mascaras before I took Clinique off my Makeup Without Cruelty list. My hope is that Clinique will soon make it back on my list!

Buxom Last by Bare Escentuals in "Blackest Black". I wanted to love it. But oh my gosh, this is the gloppiest mascara I've ever used. After I got it on, I tried getting the globs out with my mascara comb, and they wouldn't come out!

Almay One Coat Nourishing Mascara triple effect in "blackest black". Not bad, but still a little bit globby. Maybe it's me, I keep buying globby mascaras.

Revlon 3D Extreme Mascara in "Blackest Black". I must have done something terrible to a mascara in a past lifetime. This is yet another gloppy one. I mean, I wouldn't even leave my apartment with this mascara on. I'm going to try it with a different brush and see if I can't get it on right. The color is great, that's what's so frustrating, it just won't go on evenly.

Too Faced Lash Injection. I couldn't read the official color (need glasses), but it's black. And guess what? It doesn't clump!!!!! It's my fave mascara. Goes on thick and makes gorgeous lashes, yet is not goopy, extend-y, or anything else gross, it just makes lashes look gorgeous and natural.